Pros
Vegan diets have clear cardiovascular health benefits. Research shows lower heart disease and improved blood lipid profile (i.e., lower total and LDL cholesterol) for vegans. These benefits likely result from eliminating dietary cholesterol, reducing saturated fat intake, and increasing fibre and plant food intake.
Several studies have shown weight loss for those following vegan diets compared to omnivores, particularly in overweight or obese people and type 2 diabetics. The diet's high fibre content, low energy density, and its favourable effects on your gut microbiota probably contribute to its health benefits.
Vegans typically maintain lower body weights compared to omnivores, and the metabolic health improvements include better blood sugar control for type 2 diabetics and prediabetics. Studies show the diet reduces inflammation, and some evidence indicates lower rates of certain cancers.
Cons
The diet creates a risk of inadequate intake of vitamin B12, vitamin D, calcium, zinc, iodine, and selenium without careful planning. Vitamin B12 supplementation is essential. Bone health problems also arise from several nutrient inadequacies.
Some research suggests vegans may have lower bone density and potentially higher fracture risk (likely due to insufficient calcium, vitamin D, and high-quality protein intake). These risks require proactive planning through fortified foods and supplementation.
Protein quality and quantity may also be inadequate without careful planning. While total protein intake can meet recommendations, plant proteins generally have lower digestibility and sub-optimal amino acid profiles compared to animal proteins. So this may require eating a variety of different plant foods throughout the day.
Practical challenges include limited food options in many social settings, restaurants, and travel options, which make the diet difficult to follow. Long-term adherence rates are typically low, likely due to social eating limitations, increased meal planning demands, higher costs for speciality products, and the need for dietary supplements.
The increasing availability of highly processed vegan products (sometimes called 'vegan junk food'), while improving convenience, can also compromise nutritional quality. Replacing healthy foods with ‘vegan junk foods’ can potentially offset any health benefits.
Bottom Line
Eliminating animal products reduces intake of some things that can worsen your health (e.g., saturated fat, dietary cholesterol, and potential contaminants like hormones, antibiotics). Increasing your intake of plant foods also provides fibre, essential nutrients and protective ‘phytonutrients’.
So, well-planned vegan diets can offer cardiovascular and weight loss benefits, with some reduced risk of other diseases. However, supplementation, careful nutrient planning, and monitoring for deficiencies are also required, making the diet suitable for motivated people who are willing to invest in nutrition education and ongoing dietary attention — the health benefits may not be enough alone.