Pros
The diet has impressive health benefits, which are most obviously seen in the older Okinawans themselves. Long-term adherence to the diet is linked with low chances of age-related diseases, cardiovascular disease and some cancers, leading to longer and healthier lives.
The diet's cardiovascular health benefits are proven, with low rates of coronary heart disease and stroke among its followers. Emerging evidence also suggests the diet has ‘neuroprotective’ (brain health) effects, leading to lower rates of dementia and better cognitive function as you age.
Lifelong adherence to the diet is also linked with healthier body weights, little weight gain as you age, and low body fat. The diet naturally restricts calories, being around 20-40% than a typical Western diet. This is thought to occur without hunger due to the high volume of vegetables and dietary fibre in the diet. Some studies using “Okinawa-inspired” diets show weight loss and improved metabolic health markers in type 2 diabetics.
Cons
Most research involves older Okinawans who maintain these traditional eating patterns throughout their lives. This makes it uncertain whether adopting the diet later in life, or in different people, will produce the same benefits. Other lifestyle, genetic, social or environmental factors possibly contribute to the Okinawans' longevity (besides just the diet).
There are also significant practical challenges if you’re going to follow it and you don’t live in Okinawa. Many traditional Okinawan ingredients are difficult to source outside the region (e.g., goya, seaweed, beni-imo). There is also cultural unfamiliarity with preparation methods, long preparation time for some of the dishes, and the acquired taste for certain foods may also make it difficult to follow.
There are also concerning trends inside the region, with the diet declining in popularity even among Okinawans themselves. Younger Okinawans have adopted Westernised diets featuring increased meat consumption, processed foods, and eating less vegetables.
This ‘modernisation’ has coincided with deteriorating health markers and reduced life expectancy in Okinawa, raising questions about the diet's sustainability or suitability in the modern world. It remains uncertain whether the diet can be successfully used to control healthy body weights and cardiometabolic health outside of older Okinawans.
Bottom Line
The traditional Okinawan diet is strongly linked with longevity and healthy ageing, though the observations may reflect a combination of dietary, genetic, and lifestyle factors of the older Okinawan generations.
There are also practical challenges, with limited high-quality evidence showing it works outside (or sometimes within) the region. The declining adherence even in Okinawa suggests it functions best within its original cultural and environmental context, rather than as a universally applicable diet. Nevertheless, the diet in itself is difficult to fault and offers several (healthy) unique eating habits that are not found elsewhere.