Pros
The diet is based on the associations between diet, life expectancy, disease risk, and quality of life (particularly in older adults). The diet is rich in foods that are known to reduce inflammation, cardiovascular disease risk and metabolic health. The diet provides an array of nutrients, and there is very little risk of any nutrient deficiency or of consuming too much food.
For weight loss, plant-based ‘Mediterranean-style’ diets (like the blue zone diet) are associated with healthy body weights and lower risk of obesity, particularly when they are combined with active lifestyles. For weight loss, the diet is probably more sustainable than diets that eliminate entire food groups, severely restrict food intake or calorie-counting ones.
Cons
While the story behind the blue zone diet is compelling, there’s little high-quality evidence that it works outside the regions where it’s practised. The people in the blue zones are also known to practice other healthy lifestyle habits that have little to do with their diet (e.g., social life, low work and general stress, being physically active and other cultural practices).
Following this diet can be challenging outside of the blue zone regions may be challenging. These regions have well-developed cultural, familial, economic, communal and agricultural systems in place, which may not be in place in other regions. The availability of food (year-round), the cost, cooking skills, free time, and social norms can create problems for some people.
Bottom Line
The Blue Zone diet is what some of the healthiest people in the world follow. It is a whole food, plant-based diet, which provides excellent nutrition and few safety concerns. However, in our opinion, it lacks high-quality evidence showing that it works (on mass) for people outside these regions.
In theory, the diet should be suitable for people who want a flexible, sustainable diet that’s good for their general health and healthy ageing. However, it does require some social support, cooking skills and other lifestyle changes to be successful.