Pros
The ketogenic diet leads to quick weight loss and metabolic health benefits, particularly for people who’re already obese and/or have type 2 diabetes. The ‘initial’ weight loss on the keto diet (i.e., first 6 to 12 months) is a bit quicker than most other diets. However, after a year, there doesn’t appear to be any weight loss benefits.
The ‘metabolic health’ benefits are also well-documented. People who follow the diet have reported improved blood sugar and blood lipid profiles. People with type 2 diabetes experience substantial improvements in health, sometimes allowing their medication to be reduced (under close medical supervision). The diet also leads to notable increases in the good “HDL” cholesterol and decreases in blood triglycerides (important markers of cardiovascular health).
Beyond the cardiometabolic health benefits, the diet remains an effective treatment for drug-resistant epilepsy. There’s strong evidence suggesting it reduces seizures in both children and adults. Emerging research suggests there are some potential benefits for the gut microbiome, as well as some neurological conditions.
Cons
The diet's very low carbohydrate intake can limit intake of dietary fibre, several vitamins and minerals (e.g., B vitamins, vitamin C, magnesium, and potassium), and other nutrients found in plants and whole grains. Without careful planning (and probably supplementation), this could lead to nutrient deficiencies and increase disease risk.
A common concern is the elevated low-density lipoprotein (‘LDL’) cholesterol that is reported in a lot of people who follow the diet. This raises questions about long-term cardiovascular health risk despite improvements in other blood lipids.
There are also well-known side effects, sometimes called the ‘keto flu’, which include fatigue, headaches, irritability, constipation, nausea, and muscle cramps. However, these typically stop within days or weeks of following the diet. The more serious potential complications include kidney stones, nutrient deficiencies, and gut problems.
In practice, maintaining the diet can be difficult. The diet's highly restrictive nature, high cost, limited food choices, and social barriers make the diet (relatively) difficult to follow long-term. A lot of people struggle to stay in ketosis without education and support from someone who knows what they are doing.
Bottom Line
The ketogenic diet is effective for short-term weight loss and metabolic health improvements, particularly for people who are overweight, obese, and have type 2 diabetes. However, concerns remain about its effects on cholesterol levels, nutrient content, how easy it is to follow, and long-term health risks.