Pros
Low-fat diets show clear cardiovascular health benefits, particularly when saturated fats are replaced with healthier unsaturated fats or ‘complex’ (whole food, whole grain) carbohydrates. There is evidence showing that cardiovascular health risks can be reduced further when weight loss occurs, which is also reported in overweight or obese people who follow the diet.
When well-planned with adequate protein and healthy carbohydrates from whole grains, fruits, and vegetables, low-fat diets can provide complete nutrition (and all-round health). The emphasis on plant-based foods also naturally increases intake of dietary fibre, vitamins, minerals, and phytonutrients. The diet's accessibility and compatibility with many ‘cultural’ (carbohydrate-based) eating patterns contribute to its appeal.
Cons
Evidence for low-fat diets' superiority over other diets is mixed. Long-term studies show no consistent advantage over other balanced diets for weight loss, with many studies demonstrating equal outcomes after 12 months. Researchers generally report little differences in health markers for low-fat dieters (e.g., lipid profile, blood pressure, or blood sugar levels) compared to diets with moderate fat intake.
Very-low-fat diets (below 15% of calories) can increase the risk of nutrient deficiencies and higher intake of refined carbohydrates or sugars. Severely restricting dietary fat also likely reduces the intake of essential fats and fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K) that are needed for good health. Studies also report decreased testosterone levels in men following very-low-fat diets, raising concerns about hormonal effects.
The diet's lower ‘satiety’ compared to higher-fat or higher-protein diets may be challenging for some people who struggle to control their appetite. Fat adds flavour to food and helps it feel satisfying, so restricting it can make meals less enjoyable. In practice, many people find low-fat diets difficult to sustain in the long term.
Bottom Line
Low-fat diets can support modest weight loss, cardiovascular and metabolic health benefits when thoughtfully done. However, low-fat diets are not clearly superior to other balanced diets and can potentially pose risks if taken to extremes. Modern evidence supports promoting fat quality over quantity, making moderate-fat diets (i.e., 15-30% total calorie intake) with healthy fat sources preferable for most people.