Pros
Intermittent fasting is associated with several health benefits. Studies show that it results in weight loss, comparable to traditional calorie-restriction diets, alongside improved body composition and metabolic health markers.
Studies have shown that it can help normalise blood pressure, blood sugar and blood lipid profiles in people who have high levels already. Improved control of appetite and beneficial changes to the gut microbiome have also been reported. The structured eating schedule may help some people control their calorie intake without the constant vigilance required by other (more traditional) calorie-restriction diets.
Cons
While the health benefits are obvious, intermittent fasting doesn’t seem to be superior to other standard calorie-restriction diets. Different people also seem to respond differently to fasts, with some people meaningfully improving their health, while others don’t seem to respond as well.
There are no clear indicators at the moment for who may (or may not) benefit from intermittent fasts. There have also been questions about the long-term sustainability of intermittent fasts (and their health benefits), and whether some people may have problems getting all the essential nutrients they need in shorter eating windows.
There are also some practical challenges. A lot of people struggle with hunger when starting intermittent fasts; fatigue, irritability, headaches and gut problems have also been reported. A strict fasting schedule can also conflict with family meals, social gatherings, work tasks, or some cultural practices. Shift workers, people with irregular work patterns, and those who’re exercising a lot may find intermittent fasting difficult.
Intermittent fasts are also not recommended for certain people, including pregnant or breastfeeding women, people with histories of eating disorders (where rigid eating rules may trigger disordered eating patterns), children and adolescents, and people with certain medical conditions requiring regular food intake.
Bottom Line
Intermittent fasting is (in most cases) a safe, effective approach for weight loss and improving metabolic health, with benefits comparable to traditional calorie-restriction diets. However, the sustainability and the variable responses suggest it is one effective option among several, rather than the sole dietary solution to health.